“You can’t have one team with a really good scrum and try to get them out of it,” Mike Ross told me, before adding his own question. “How about you just improve a bit?”
Watch the Nations Championship – Round 5 LIVE
Hemispheres collide in a new championship of nations. Stream live, replays and highlights for free on RugbyPass TV.
It was the Monday after Ireland he was clipped, crumpled and trampled by punishing Springbok packs. Irish supporters roared and jeered last Saturday as the Boks tried to take their side back to the Stone Age. It was a humbling night.
Among the suggestions offered on social media, podcasts, commentary and the national airwaves were forcing direct scrum feeds (requiring the attacking whore to be hooked), awarding free kicks for kicks in the air and not allowing teams to select ‘scrum’ when they receive a scrum penalty. The island was searching for answers, and Ross, a sick-headed Irishman, was the voice of reason. Get busy. Get better.
As soon as the final whistle blew, in Dublin on November 22n.d In 2025, most rugby fans were aware that the second leg was already booked. Three hundred and sixty-four days later, same place, slightly different lineups, new silverware in order. Ireland had a year to plug the broken hatches. The storm is almost here. Time and schedule will tell if their defense holds up.
“I want to be the next Vol. I want to be the next Malcolm”
Andrew ‘Tank’ Lanning has been coaching young, hopeful scrummagers for as long as he can remember. It’s always been a privilege – to feed on that South African love of forwardness. He is a scrum mentor at Stormers Institute, in Stellenbosch, and scrum coach for the Stormers U20 side. The work, for the longest time, was tiring and far from the spotlight. In recent years, however, it has become increasingly busy. Scrum dogs are now superstars.
“Scrummaging is a big part of the Springboks culture now,” says Lanning. “I have young 13- and 14-year-old boys coming in who in the old days wanted to be the next Danie Gerber, Jean de Villiers, Schalk Burger or Duane Vermeulen. I promise you, I have Drawers (young people) who come and say, ‘I want to be the next Ox Nché. I want to be the next Malcolm Marx’. They became national heroes.
“The Bomb Squad has played a big part in that as well. Rassie brings six forwards at once. The young players see that and want to be the next Bomb Squad.”
“I started the scrum school, about six years ago,” he adds, “because I saw that a lot of coaches didn’t have time for individual work. Now I have under-nines or under-10s coming in, which, personally, I think is ridiculous. But that’s what the Springbok scrum has done.”
An ardent student of the scrum, Lanning notes how Argentina – with their Bajada (eight-man push) techniques – had an early jump on rival nations. The pack as a brotherhood is something that has gained momentum due to changes in the law, elsewhere. “In South Africa,” explains Tank, “there’s always been dominance up front and basing the game on gaining an advantage, there. Since they’ve kicked a driving maul from the line, the easiest way for the Boks to get a penalty is through a scrum. Then, you kick in the corner and go for a driving maul. It’s become so incredibly, over the last 10 years, ingrained in our rugby culture.
“Another thing that is very much a part of South African culture, certainly with Africans, is just the size of the players. These Africans are on the farm – basically they were born to eat meat, carry huge bales of straw and work on the farm.”
If you were to design your perfect prop and put all your points into scrummaging, you’d get it with Wilco Louw
Mike Ross, former Ireland prop
In the professional era of rugby, Lanning feels that Os du Randt was the first superstar to fight for the South African fans. Tendai Mtawarira, who moved from flank to prop, was the next to be credited for breaking the British and Irish Lions Scrum, 2009. Du Randt and Mtawarira could move around the park if needed. Lanning noted how, since World Rugby required a loose and firm cover on the substitutes’ bench, props can now be ‘less mobile, smashing animals’ that don’t have to last the full 80 minutes.
“If you were to design your perfect prop,” Ross said last year, “and put all your points into scrummaging, you’d get it with Wilco Lowe.”
Louw, who weighs 135 kilograms, is the prototype animal to which Lanning refers. He is not the only one available to Rasie Erasmus and his coaching staff. When Ireland faced the Boks in Dublin last November, their starting pack (916kg) was 32kg lighter than South Africa’s. Last week in Paris, the world champions had a 64-kilogram lead over France, which gave away eight penalties.

Lanning tries to put into simple terms just how much a heavier pack can mean when both sides are packed. “64 kg,” he exclaims. “Imagine that. He’s huge. That’s eight pounds per striker. That makes a huge difference, especially down the stiff side. Wilco is a monster. Depending on whether he’s had a steak for lunch or not, Wilco is between 135 and 140. Hips like a big tight lock, so another hip is 120kg to 120kg and 18kg. 120, you’re talking 360 to 370 kilos landing on one side of the scrum.
The quality of the opposition is also crucial. Iron sharpens iron. With the likes of Andrew Porter and Tadhg Furlong battling it out against Sam Illo and Tom O’Toole in training, the Boks have a seemingly endless stream of superb scrummagers. “When (Stormers stalwart) Neethling Fouché spent some time with the Springboks,” Lanning says, “he obviously had to earn his kicks. He was always in the pack going up against Ox and Wilco. He said to me, ‘It was very tough'”.
Ireland will be looking to do everything in their power to minimize the amount of fracas that referee Christopher Ridley and his touch judges have to oversee on Saturday. France and New Zealand he has proved adept, in recent clashes, at quick scrum feeds that clear the ball before the Boks pack get to work. Jamison Gibson-Park and Craig Casey will be unsuccessfully trying to do it again, in training, this whole time Nations Championship window.
Ireland usually like to send forwards, but don’t be surprised if Gibson-Park and Sam Prendergast send their shots longer. Airstrikes, on either side, are not what they are looking for. Irish bouncers will be told to return balls if they don’t think they can make a good catch. However, not all quarrels can be avoided. Ireland is also helped by Joe McCarthy in the second row. They will be boosted by Porter, Furlong and Illo who have won multiple penalties in recent games, while conceding Saturday’s task will be daunting.

Irish supporters are realistic. Parity may be a dream. However, if the Irish pack can minimize the impact of the Springboks, the home crowd and team will feel they have a chance.
“I’d like to think I’m more of a ball player”
Fierce battles and personal competitions will be held in all corners of the Aviva Stadium this weekend.
Going into the clash of partnerships, it will be fascinating to see who will have the upper hand between the veteran midfield ranks. Stuart McCloskey and Robbie Henshaw (67 combined) will face off against Jesse Kriel and Damian de Allende (66). The four men walked several blocks and were knocked down by several more.
McCloskey, in the form of his life at 34, relishes the challenge. “Damian De Allende will probably go down as one of the best 12s to play the game,” he says. “Overall, though, we’ve always had a pretty good, even contest whenever we play each other.”
“I played against De Allende and Kriel a few times,” he adds, “and then I played against Damian a few more times when he was at Munster. They’re very physical. De Allende is such a workhorse, with the amount of runs he goes through, the damage he does at breakdowns and defensively. That’s his key.

“We’re a little bit different, that way. People would assume that I like to do that, too. And, yeah, I do that a little bit, but I’d like to think I’m a little bit more of a ball player than him. He does some physical things a little bit better. I’d like to be on his level, in terms of that. He’s a great player.
“So Kriel is just an athlete. He’s probably one of the best athletic 13s you’ll ever see. He’s still got the break in him and, like all the South African team, he’ll make the breakdown an absolute nightmare.”





























































