A bittersweet Welsh joke as the national team prepares for their upcoming game against the mighty All black people: the coach takes the players to the field for training. He stops and says, ‘Okay guys, take your usual positions.’ Without pausing to think, the players go to the other end of the field and huddle under the post. Some are already looking up to see Beauden Barrett or Richie Mo’unga skip the conversion in their mind.
Save 20% on Emirates Dubai 7s tickets with HSBC
We would like to offer our customers a 20% discount on the first 800 tickets on Friday, Saturday and Sunday. Activate the offer via the Special Offers section of the Emirates Dubai 7s app and complete your purchase with your HSBC card or debit card.
It’s the kind of dark humor that always circulates along the M4 corridor, and gushes up and down the valleys of the South Wales when New Zealand is coming to town. I clearly remember the two times they came closest to winning. At the old Arms Park in 1978, Wales were without Gareth Edwards and Phil Bennett, but the rest of the Grand Slam-winning squad was intact. Wales led 12-10 when English referee Roger Quittenton awarded the All Blacks a penalty after Frank Oliver and Andy Haden were ejected from the final line-up. Brian McKechnie scored the game-winning goal.
“I knew straight away it was a hoax. When we found out later that they had planned it the night before, it really hit me. I’ll never forget it as long as I live,” said the Pontypool, Wales and British & Irish Lions whore Bobby Windsor after that.
The dinner table after the game was shared by the players of both teams. ‘Could you pass the salt and pepper?’ Haden inquired about Geoff Wheel in the Wales second row sitting next to him. The wheel pushed the pots. There was a momentary silence as they rolled over. ‘Where have I seen that before?’ ‘Mumbles Ripper’ muttered. Black humor, see.
The second time was in November 2004, when I graduated from fan to insider. At the time I was working on Mike Ruddock’s staff, scouting Wales’ opponents and helping to build a strategy against them. We lost agonizingly by one point, 25-26. We could have won the game.
With Wales trailing by four points, but with the weight of a penalty in the Kiwi 22 as the clock ticked down, captain Gareth Thomas opted to take a goal kick, which Gavin Henson slotted over, rather than opting for a corner kick. “They really pressed us,” rookie skipper Richie McCaw said afterward. “If they had had a crack, God knows what would have happened.” God only knows, but at least Wales won the Grand Slam the following season for the first time in 27 years. That was some compensation.
The pitch may have been turned 90 degrees, the old Arms Park has long since become the Principality Stadium, but the heroes of 1953 have finally been honoured. For the first time in 73 years, Wales beat the All Blacks last weekend. It really is a lifetime for most people.
For Wales it will mark a turning point, but it is just one step along the winding road back to rugby respectability. Head Coach Steve Tandy is a down-to-earth Neath Valley man, the salt of good Tonmawr soil. They will remember very well that Wales have lost their last two games to the world champions Springboks by a combined score of 116-0, home and away, over the last 12 months. Forget the weekend of tears and hysteria, they will have to wait for the cold light of Monday morning. Tandy has built his rugby life around strong defense rather than free-flowing attack.
Make no mistake, the defense won the game for the Red Dragons on Saturday afternoon, and that will also have a cascading effect on All Blacks supremo Dave Rennie’s future planning.
Back in 2018, he went to the far side of the world and settled in Australia, willing to pass through the country for free. He ended up as defense coach of Super Rugby’s Waratahs, building a ‘blue wall’ in New South Wales rather than his native South Wales. On his return, he built another blue wall, this time a darker shade for Gregor Townsend’s Scotland, over the next six years.
He has been appointed as defense coach for Warren Gatland’s ill-fated tour amid the Covid Lions South Africa 2021. Bok’s mark is on him and Tandy will never forget him. In his view, there will be no new Wales without a solid defensive foundation.
Make no mistake, the defense won the game for the Red Dragons on Saturday afternoon, and that will also have a cascading effect on All Blacks supremo Dave Rennie’s future planning. The intellectual washing of this result will not go quietly into the night. It won’t be dismissed as a one-off, especially with England looming on the horizon at the Old Cabbage Patch in the sixth round of the Nations Championship.

Rennie’s comments as the dust began to clear were very revealing: “It’s been a challenging couple of days after the game and again yesterday, it’s a very quiet group. That feeling, they know we’ve let ourselves down, we’ve let the country down.”
“A lot of the things we talked about weren’t a lack of effort. Our ability to make the obvious is our point of difference, and a lot of the things we show are six-on-twos and five-on-twos, and the short ball to someone in the hole (on).
“He has no one in front of him, and there were probably about 10 such examples. Maybe under pressure, it just became really tunnel-visioned and brought into contact, and we didn’t do the obvious.
“We talked about it. We talked about the pressure guys were feeling and the confidence in our structure. That if we’re really disciplined about it, then we’re going to get the ball into space, wherever that space is.”
The level of interest in those observations peaks when compared to the reaction of assistant striker Neil Barnes:
“There was actually a message at half-time that we wanted to go a bit more into the driving line. But sometimes, when you have a penalty five meters from the goal line, you risk not even winning that ball.”
“But the last one in particular, I know Jason Ryan was yelling that we should go to our driving maul. Personally? Yeah, I’d go to the line maul.”
While the two advanced coaches talk about a different game with the driving line-up, the main one still bangs on about doing more with the ball in hand outside of it. That conversation becomes even more fascinating when you look at the attacking stats Rennie’s All Blacks are generating after five rounds Nations Championship play:
The All Blacks are so far ahead of the attacking curve – five minutes more time spent with the ball in hand, 42 more hand placements above average – that most other nations in the tournament can only watch their dust trail in the distance, and the same statistic from the Cardiff match was even more eye-watering:
Wales may have been forced into 353 clearance attempts over the course of 80 minutes, but they never got off their feet and were still finishing at over 92% by the end of the match. 19 handles per break and 48 handles per attempt are not efficient scoring averages. You can almost hear Rassie grinning in the background.
In the last half hour, the All Blacks abandoned the close-range maul and completely forgot that kicking the ball is as progressive a way of using space as running and passing. When does the concept of identity become an obsession? The defeat to Wales raised a very red flag against the essence of the Rennie model of the game.
In the final 30 minutes, the All Blacks continued to make breaks but kept them away from the Welsh goal line:
https://t.co/ypGU39Bzpl
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
As soon as Wales defended in their own half, they added an extra body to the line and left a lone man in the backfield:
It is notoriously difficult to break down a 14-man defensive line with the ball in hand, and the men in black did not make any significant line breaks on the red brick wall, nor did they produce any attacking shots into the attractive spaces either side of a single full-back defender. The lack of basic intelligence in the game was breathtaking, especially when you consider the combined experience of the two men in the starting spots at No.10 and No.15:
https://t.co/OwaymnJdcu
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
https://t.co/jfoHzZ0871
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
https://t.co/2muXxHMryv
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
By the end of the match, Wales presented their 14-man wall well behind the halfway line, as they knew New Zealand would run through their formations ball in hand without any threat of balancing from the boot. Even when a break is made, the density of the 14-man line allows plenty of time to recover in the first two clips of the next few plays.
Rennie’s philosophy of twitching is in great danger of crashing on the rocks of predictability. Against a stubborn Welsh defense modeled after their head coach Tandy, the All Blacks enjoyed enough to win two games of rugby, let alone one.
But they never produced enough variety in the final half hour – no attacking punches, no movement from the line – to deserve victory. Tandy outwitted Rennie in the coaching box, and the leaders on the field could neither change nor reverse the trends set in concrete in the second period.
With England next up, New Zealand’s coaching staff will continue to be in red. And another troubadour from the Neath Valley, Max Boyce, would bring an incredible triumph to rugby folklore in years to come:
“There’s an old Welsh saying that I like, that I should turn to song.
“It says, with just a few simple words, that every wait is long.
“But now that wait is over and many tears have been shed.
“When New Zealand was defeated and the clock turned red.”