Rugby

‘A bad day at the office, or did Wales expose fundamental All Blacks problems?’


These days with All black peopleeverything is more about the trajectory than the results. This effectively means that the All Blacks are judged more on vibes than win ratio, but this is how it is after former coach Scott Robertson was sacked earlier this year.

The official world ranking list in the app 📱

You can now check the official international world rankings in the RugbyPass app!

Robertson delivered a 74% win rate, but according to New Zealand Rugby chair, David Kirk: “We didn’t see the trajectory we wanted and the fans will probably share that view that there were things about the way we played and the way we failed to achieve the excellence we were looking for that were never addressed during the year.”

This brave new world of judging by feel rather than cold, hard statistics is good news for current manager Dave Rennie who has won seven and lost four for a 64% win ratio since taking over in March.

That’s a low return by the standards set by any of his peers and looking at that number against Steve Hansen’s 87%, Graham Henry’s 85% and John Mitchell’s 82%, it doesn’t look great.

There are positive signs in Dave Rennie’s early struggles at the reins, but his win rate has yet to match that of his predecessors (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

But there are mitigating factors. Rennie only got the job in March while he was the coach Japan and so he had to pick a team remotely and try to sort out his coaching staff and management group from afar.

He’s also been handed one of the most brutal and demanding schedules of the professional age – starting with the Test apiece against France then Ireland before embarking on an eight-game tour South Africa which included four tests, the last of which was in Baltimore, USA.

Then came the two-Test Bledisloe series before the final match of the Nations Championship. It’s not a longer itinerary than any of his predecessors, but the tour of South Africa was extremely physically and mentally demanding.

These are not excuses – just facts – and form part of the context in trying to understand how the All Blacks, ranked second in the world, ended up losing by 10th-set Wales.

It will be one of the great sporting mysteries, best attributed to an incredibly brave and resilient performance from Wales. Sport does that – it brings great and inspiring stories, and this one was so good: a written-off Wales, with no chance, stunned the All Blacks with the performance of a lifetime.

So the Welsh defeat was simply a crazy day at the office, or a sign that there was something fundamentally wrong with the All Blacks that had not previously been realized until Wales exposed?

Nobody saw this result coming. There was not a shred of evidence that Wales could compete in the way they did and the question is what to make of the trajectory of the All Blacks.

Ahead of the Cardiff game, there was confidence that they were on the right track – despite a 3-1 series defeat to South Africa – picking the right players, playing the right brand of rugby and executing it well. They attacked incisively – scoring more tries than in 2024 and 2025 – had a developing kicking game and appeared united and solid, with a thorough respect for the coaching staff.

So was the Welsh defeat just a crazy day at the office, or a sign that there was something fundamentally wrong with the All Blacks that hadn’t been realized until Wales exposed it?

Rennie appeared to subscribe to the former when he faced the media in London. “We picked a very good side, and a side that I was really confident that if we played to our potential, would do well,” he said.

“It wasn’t a lack of effort, but our ability to do it obviously is our point of difference and a lot of the things we show are six-on-twos and five-on-twos or a short ball to someone in the hole who doesn’t have anyone in front of them.

New Zealand struggled to find the killer touch to take advantage of Cardiff’s abundance of possession and territory (Photo by Jan Kruger – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images)

“There were probably 10 or so examples of that. Maybe it’s under pressure that they just got really tunnel-visioned and put in touch and didn’t do the obvious, so we talked about that.”

Rennie reckoned his team created enough chances to win, but inexplicably capitalized poorly on them. The incredible resistance of the Welsh defense also increased the pressure and the All Blacks, who made 10 changes to their team last week, melted away.

And, perhaps, when Ethan de Groot, Codie Taylor, Fabian Holland, Tupou Vaa’i, Cam Roigard, Damian McKenzie, Jordie Barrett and Will Jordan are recalled due to England In the game, the All Blacks return to their winning ways and reset their trajectory.

But stepping back from the vibes for a moment and taking a closer look at the data tells a story that cannot be denied.

It would be financially disastrous to leave Super Rugby and go it alone, but does it make high performance sense to continue working with Australians who show little sign of improvement?

The All Blacks have seen their win ratio drop from 87% between 2010 and 2019 to 72% between 2020 and 2026. In the last six years, the All Blacks have also suffered a historic first defeat against Argentina (they then lost twice more against Pumas) and a first defeat against Wales. The win ratio against South Africa since 2020 is 28%, against France and Ireland is 57% and against England is 50%.

Also, the disappearance of the New Zealand under-20 team is telling. Having been untouchable when the tournament first started in 2008, New Zealand are now struggling to keep up with South Africa, England and France. Wins came in 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2015 and 2017 – but no title has come since then, and on two occasions in the last eight years, New Zealand have failed to reach the semi-finals.

He had a high-performance meltdown of sorts, and NZR recognized just that by making the decision to completely restructure the department and bring in heavy hitters Don Tricker, Conrad Smith and Michael Collins. These three could do well to lead improved communication between all parties and build tighter, better-marked paths for elite players. Their idea to merge Blues with Auckland, and all the other big urban unions with their Super Rugby clubs, can prove inspired.

However, the question remains whether New Zealand’s elite players are exposed to tough enough professional competition.

The decision has already been made to reject the plan to blow up Super Rugby and build a 10-team domestic professional competition and instead continue with things as they are. NZR says the 10-team proposal would increase player wages by $33 million and reduce the value of broadcasting rights to leave the national body with an annual deficit of $40 million.

It would be financially disastrous to leave Super Rugby and go it alone, but does it make high performance sense to continue working with Australians who show little sign of improvement?

Super Rugby Pacific may not provide the same strength of competition as previous iterations involving South African franchises (Photo by PA)

Again, sticking to the facts, no Australian team has ever won a play-off game in New Zealand, and none of the Waratahs, Red or Force have consistently been good enough to regularly beat Kiwi teams over the last four years. The Brumbies were an exception, but they disappeared this year.

New Zealand’s high-performance decision-makers say, however, that the country’s elite players need a level between the NPC and the All Blacks and that Super Rugby is best placed to act as that bridge. Rennie was asked if he supported continuing the current system, and if so, why.

He said: “Yes. I am. I think the NPC is key and I think that’s our difference. There’s a lot of countries in the world that would like to have a semi-professional competition like we do and as we can see there’s a steady stream of kids who end up going into the Super Rugby competition which we also need to step up in international rugby.

“In the old days when you had the African teams there and you had to deal with the travel and the attitude and all the other things that go with it, it was a real high-quality competition.

“Now it’s more trans-Tasman and it’s probably not quite what it used to be, but it’s probably the best we can do at this point.

“I know there’s been a lot of thinking about how we can get some cross-matches or how we can bring in other teams. I’m not sure how likely it is, but there would be two, three or four Japanese clubs keen to join the competition at some stage and that might allow us to pick players from that competition because you’re comparing apples to apples.

“Financially, some planning needs to be done, but I think it’s the right decision to keep both of those competitions.”

The All Blacks cannot afford, in the long term, for there to be a gap between their results and trajectory and Super Rugby needs to start making the case that it is the right vehicle for New Zealand’s elite players.





Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

MLB

Top Dodgers prospect Josue De Paula spoke ahead of his highly anticipated Major League debut after receiving a surprise call-up directly from Double-A. “You’re...

MLB

Julian McWilliams joins CBS Sports HQ to recap the biggest storylines after the first week of the 2026 MLB Season. [00:00:00] ABS Challenge Systen...

MLB

Josue De Paula celebrated his first National League West championship just days after making his major league debut with the Dodgers. De Paula described...

MLB

Lewis Brinson joins CBS Sports HQ to discuss the best fits for players who could get dealt at the MLB Trade Deadline. [00:00:00] Intro...

Copyright © 2026 LewLewSports - All rights reserved.

Exit mobile version